Implementing Mental Practice in Postgraduate Surgical Training for Minimally Invasive Surgery: A Systematic Review and Thematic Analysis.

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Unprecedented pressure on the National Health Service (NHS) has meant that there are increasing obstacles to surgical training. Simulation training is an option to improve surgical performance but is limited due to availability, accessibility and financial constraints. Mental practice (MP) has been proposed as a potential solution to supplement the traditional method of apprenticeship-style learning. Despite increasing evidence that MP may be a useful tool to improve surgical performance and reduce surgeon anxiety, it is not widely adopted. This systematic review and thematic analysis aims to identify key themes that would allow for the successful implementation of MP in postgraduate surgical training. METHODS: Medline, Embase and PsycINFO databases were systematically searched to identify articles that investigate the role of MP in improving surgical performance amongst surgical trainees. Retrieved papers were studied to inform thematic analysis of their content and studies were assessed for bias. RESULTS: A total of 321 studies were retrieved, of which 11 met the inclusion criteria. Overall risk of bias was assessed to be between critical and moderate for seven nonrandomized studies and between fair and good for four randomized studies. Key themes were identified and discussed using a thematic analysis approach. CONCLUSION: This study has identified that attaining high quality mental imagery is fundamental to success in mental practice and this can be augmented by the use of relaxation therapy and/or motivational imagery. Future research should focus on the application of MP in real-world surgical practice and breaking down complex procedures into fewer operative steps.